North Dakota WSI Employer Appeals

If a Workforce Safety and Insurance audit concluded that the people you paid as independent contractors were actually your employees, you are looking at back premium, penalties, and interest — often for years of payroll you have already spent.

You have 45 days from the date of the Notice of Decision to appeal, and the appeal must be in writing and state why you believe the audit results are wrong. The clock runs from the date on the letter, not from the day you opened it, so some of those 45 days are gone before the envelope reaches you.

At Yunker Law, I represent North Dakota employers against WSI in audits, misclassification disputes, and administrative appeals.

Who this page is for:

  • Employers who received a Notice of Decision after a WSI premium audit

  • Businesses reclassified from independent contractor to employer-employee status

  • General contractors held responsible for an uninsured subcontractor's unpaid premium and penalties under N.D.C.C. § 65-04-26.2

  • Employers facing premium adjustments, penalties, or coverage disputes

  • Accountants and bookkeepers whose clients have received one of these notices

Why these audits catch good employers

Two beliefs are almost universal among North Dakota business owners, and both of them are wrong.

"I issued a 1099, so he is a contractor."

How a worker is paid is not what determines the answer. WSI applies a multi-factor common law test that looks at behavioral control, financial control, and the nature of the relationship. The tax form you issued is not on the list.

"He has an exemption certificate from another state."

An exemption issued elsewhere does not transfer into North Dakota. North Dakota carries a presumption of employment, which means the burden is on the employer to establish that a worker is genuinely an independent contractor — not on WSI to prove that he is not.

That presumption is the reason these cases require real work. It also means the earlier you get help, the better. The record you build in the administrative process is largely the record you are stuck with on appeal.

How the process works

A WSI audit dispute is litigation, whatever it looks like on paper, and it runs through four stages.

  • Written appeal of the Notice of Decision, within 45 days of the date on the letter, stating the grounds.

  • Administrative hearing before an administrative law judge, with sworn testimony, exhibits, and cross-examination.

  • Appeal to a North Dakota district court under the administrative appeal procedure, on briefs and the administrative record.

  • Further appeal to the North Dakota Supreme Court.

An administrative hearing is a trial. Witnesses testify, documents come in, and the ALJ decides who to believe. I have tried more than 100 cases to a judge, and I have argued before the North Dakota Supreme Court. This is the same work in a different room.

What a defense looks like

The fight is over the facts of the working relationship, and those facts are provable. Who set the schedule. Who supplied the tools and the vehicle. Whether the worker could take other jobs, and whether he did. Whether he carried his own insurance, invoiced, or bore any risk of loss. Whether he could subcontract the work. Whether there was a written agreement and whether the parties actually followed it.

Often the auditor was partly right. Some workers were correctly classified and others were not, and the assessment should be a fraction of what was issued. That is worth pursuing even when a clean win is not on the table.

Common questions

How long do I have to appeal a WSI Notice of Decision?

Forty-five days from the date on the Notice of Decision. That is the date printed on the letter, not the date you received it, so the deadline is already running by the time the envelope reaches you. The appeal must be in writing and must state why you believe the determination is incorrect.


The determination becomes final and the assessment becomes collectible. There is no practical way to reopen the question later.

What happens if I do nothing?


Can I be held responsible for my subcontractor's workers?

Yes. A general contractor can be liable for unpaid premium and penalties owed by an uninsured subcontractor or independent contractor under N.D.C.C. § 65-04-26.2. This surprises contractors who did nothing wrong except hire the wrong sub.


That depends on the size of the assessment and the strength of the facts, and it is the first thing I will evaluate with you. Sometimes the answer is no. You should get that answer from a lawyer who has looked at the audit file, not from a guess.

Is it worth appealing?


I am an accountant. Can I call on behalf of a client?

Please do. You will often see the Notice of Decision before your client understands what it means, and the 45-day clock is already running when it arrives.

The clock is already running

Call (701) 504-1460 with the Notice of Decision in front of you.

I represent employers throughout North Dakota in WSI audits, misclassification disputes, and administrative appeals.